Local Appeal Tribunal case file for Arthur Rooth, aged 53, Road man at Williamthorpe Date of birth: Marital status: Married Address: 14 Bailey Square, Clay Cross Type of benefit claimed: Special Hardship Allowance Type of injury: Injury - knee Further information: The accident was November 1957 and a return to work after 3 months only lasted 6 weeks . In Medical report November 1958 : 'Traumatic neurosis present - not incapacitating'. Majority decision of Tribunal. 1959